Could an atheist be a statesman? A Mormon?, could a true statesman be Muslim? Or Jewish? Just as the classic definition of a statesman doesn’t include a person’s private relationships, which we discussed yesterday, the definition also doesn’t address matters of religion. At least in theory, religion and statesmanship are two separate things.

But, right now, questions of religious affiliation rank among the hottest headlines in news media. Can a wise, experienced, nonpartisan leader also take a minority approach toward faith? The issue is on the front cover of Newsweek. And, it’s in the blog of one of the country’s top religion newswriters: Bill Tammeus.

“Religion matters in politics only insofar as a candidate’s religious beliefs might affect public policy or his or her ability to perform the duties of the office,” Bill Tammeus writes in his blog, Faith Matters. “Beyond that it shouldn’t matter, though clearly it does to a big chunk of the population.” 

That’s the rub. Religion matters in America, and it matters a lot in politics and elections—especially in many voters’ images of acceptable statesmen.

Now that Mitt Romney is the Republican frontrunner, questions of religion arise once again. Putting aside the question of whether Romney qualifies as a statesman, could he—a Mormon—be elected president? Two-thirds (68%) of Americans say it wouldn’t matter to them if a candidate was Mormon, according to a new Pew survey. But 25% said it would, and they would be less likely to support a Mormon. Only 5% say they would be more likely to support a Mormon like Romney.

Opposition to a Mormon candidate makes odd allies. Over 40% of liberal democrats wouldn’t support a Mormon for the highest office, and about a third (34%) of white evangelical Protestants wouldn’t either. Evangelicals tend to oppose Mormons on points of religion. Liberal democrats oppose Mormons mainly because this religious group tends to be socially conservative.

The Pew poll did have some bright points. Race, ethnicity, and gender don’t seem to matter much anymore. Large majorities say that it wouldn’t matter if a candidate were black, Latino, or a woman. On this, Democrats, Republicans, and independents agree.

Do you think that religion should matter in what makes a statesman?

How do you feel about Romney as the Republican candidate?

Remember: This week I’m asking you to nominate someone for The Lincoln Award for Statesmanship. This non-partisan award is given annually by The Statesman Group.

Please, add a comment below! And spread the word on Facebook!

Originally published at, an online experiment in civil dialogue on American values.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email