In 1992, over a third of Americans (36%) said that AIDS might be God’s punishment for immoral sexual behavior. Over time, public opinion has become more supportive of gay rights and even legalized same-sex marriage. Has this trend also lessened the opinion that AIDS could be divine punishment for immorality?
The percent of Americans who now agree that AIDS is God’s punishment has dropped considerably, according to the just-released report by the Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI). But a sizable minority—14% of all Americans—still believe that AIDS is divine punishment.
We see big drops in the “divine punishment” theory across the board. In 1992, the majority of white evangelical Protestants (51%) subscribed to this explanation of AIDS; today, the percent is 24%, according to PRRI. Similarly, 50% of black Protestants in 1992 said that AIDS was God’s punishment for immoral sexual behavior, but that figure has fallen to 20% today.
Only 7% of white Catholics today perceive AIDS to be divine punishment, 10% of white mainline Protestants, and 8% of the religiously unaffiliated.
We also see differences by political party affiliation. One of four Tea Partiers (24%) today subscribe to the theory of divine punishment. About two of ten Republicans (19%) agree. Support for the idea that God uses AIDS to punish immoral sexual behavior is the lowest for Democrats (13%) and Independents (14%).
Do you agree or disagree that AIDS is God’s punishment for immoral sexual behavior?
What explains the trend towards fewer and fewer Americans believing that AIDS is divine punishment?
- LGBT Trends: Are churches ready to welcome gay and lesbian people?
- LGBT Trends: Have you seen the great generational divide?
- LGBT Trends: Who still thinks AIDS may be ‘divine punishment’?
- LGBT Trends: Is same-sex marriage a Constitutional right?
- LGBT Trends: ‘Could you see yourself performing a gay wedding?’